authors 
Tan, Milton 
year 
1990 
title 
Saying What It Is by What It Is Like  Describing Shapes Using Line Relationships 
source 
The Electronic Design Studio: Architectural Knowledge and Media in the Computer Era [CAAD Futures ‘89 Conference Proceedings / ISBN 0262132540] Cambridge (Massachusetts / USA), 1989, pp. 201213 
summary 
Shapes  taken as welldefined collections of lines  are fundamental building blocks in architectural drawings. From doodles to shop drawings, shapes are used to denote ideas and represent elements of design, many of which ultimately translate into actual objects. But because designs evolve, the shapes representing a design are seldom static  instead, they are perpetually open to transformations. And since transformations involve relationships, conventional methods of describing shapes as sets of discrete endpoints may not provide an appropriate foundation for schematic design. This paper begins with a review of the perception of shapes and its significance in design. In particular, it argues that juxtapositions and interrelationships of shapes are important seedbeds for creative development of designs. It is clear that conventional representation of shapes as sets of discrete lines does not cope with these emergent" subshapes; the most basic of which arise out of intersecting and colinear lines. Attempts to redress this by using ‘reduction rules’ based on traditional pointandline data structures are encumbered by computational problems of precision and shape specification. Basically, this means that some ‘close’ cases of subshapes may escape detection and their specifications are difficult to use in substitution operations. The paper presents the findings of a computer project  Emergence II  which explored a 'relational' description of shapes based on the concept of construction lines. It builds on the notion that architectural shapes are constructed in a graphic context and that, at a basic compositional level, the context can be set by construction lines. Accordingly, the interface enables the delineation of line segments with reference to preestablished construction lines. This results in a simple data structure where the knowledge of shapes is centralized in a lookup table of all its construction lines rather than dispersed in the specifications of line segments. Taking this approach, the prototype software shows the ease and efficiency of applying ‘reduction rules’ for intersection and colinear conditions, and for finding emergent subshapes by simply tracking the construction lines delimiting the ends of line segments. 
series 
CAAD Futures 
email 
miltontan@mac.com 
full text 
file.pdf (132,904 bytes) 
references 
Contenttype: text/plain

Arnheim, R. (1974)
Art and Visual Perception
, University of Califomia Press, Berkeley & Los Angeles. (Originally published 1954.)




Chase, S. (1989)
Shapes and Shape Grammars: from mathematical model to computer implementation
, Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, v16, pp. 216242




Krishnamurti, R. and Giraud, C. (1986)
Towards a shape editor: the implementation of a shape generation system
, Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, v13 pp. 391404




Krishnamurti, R. (1980)
The arithmetic of shapes
, Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, v7, pp. 463484




Krishnamurti, R. (1981)
The construction of shapes
, Envirorument and Planning B: Planning and Design, v8 pp. 540




Mitchell, W., Liggett, R. and Kvan, T. (1987)
The Art of Computer Graphics Programming
, Van Nostrand Reinhold, NY




Mitchell, W., Liggett, R. and Tan, M. (1988)
The Topdown System and its Use in Teaching  an exploration of structured, knowledgebased design
, Proceedings of the Association of Computeraided Design in Architecture Workshop 88




Mitchell, W., Liggett, R. and Tan, M. (1989)
On Teaching Designers to Program and Programmers to Design
, Proceedings of the 1989 CAAD Futures Conference. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA




Nagakura, T. (1989)
Shape Recognition & Transformation  a Scriptbased Approach
, Proceedings of the 1989 CAAD Futures Conference. MIT Press, Cambridge




Putnam, H. (1987)
Many Faces of Realism
, Open Court, LaSalle, Il




Stiny, G. (1989)
What Designers Do that Computers Should
, Proceedings of the 1989 CAAD Futures Conference. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA




Tan, M. (1987)
Miesing About  a computer program to investigate parametric variation of the Project for a Brick Country House
, 1923 by Mies van der Rohe. Unpublished project




Winston, P. and Horn (1989)
LISP
, AddisonWesley, Reading, MA (3rd. edition)




last changed 
2003/05/16 18:58 
