CumInCAD is a Cumulative Index about publications in Computer Aided Architectural Design
supported by the sibling associations ACADIA, CAADRIA, eCAADe, SIGraDi, ASCAAD and CAAD futures

id acadia03_036
authors Gerzso, J. Michael
year 2003
title On the Limitations of Shape Grammars: Comments on Aaron Fleisher’s Article “Grammatical Architecture?”
source Connecting >> Crossroads of Digital Discourse [Proceedings of the 2003 Annual Conference of the Association for Computer Aided Design In Architecture / ISBN 1-880250-12-8] Indianapolis (Indiana) 24-27 October 2003, pp. 279-287
summary Shape grammars were introduced by Gips and Stiny in 1972. Since then, there have been many articles and books written by them and their associates. In 1992, Aaron Fleisher, a professor at the School of Planning, MIT, wrote a critique of their work in an article titled “Grammatical Architecture?” published in the journal Environment and Planning B. According to him, Gips, Stiny and later Mitchell, propose a hypothesis that states that shape grammars are presumed to represent knowledge of architectural form, that grammars are “formable,” and that there is a visual correspondence to verbal grammar. The strong version of “the hypothesis requires that an architectural form be equivalent to a grammar.” Fleisher considers these hypotheses unsustainable, and argues his case by analyzing the differences between language, and architecture, and by dealing with the concepts of lexicons, syntax and semantics. He concludes by stating that architectural design is negotiated in two modalities: the verbal and the visual, and that equivalences are not at issue; they do not exist. If there is such thing as a language for design, it would provide the means to maintain a discussion of the consequences in one mode, of the state and conditions of the other. Fleisher’s observations serve as the basis of this paper, a tribute to him, and also an opportunity to present an outline to an alternate approach or hypothesis to shape grammars, which is “nonlinguistic” but “generative,” in the sense that it uses production rules. A basic aspect of this hypothesis is that the only similarity between syntactic rules in language and some rules in architecture is that they are recursive.
series ACADIA
full text file.pdf (262,267 bytes)
references Content-type: text/plain
details citation check to select
100%; open Aho, A. and Ullman, J. (1972) Find in CUMINCAD The theory of parsing translation and compiling, vol. 1, Parsing , Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice Hall
100%; open Aho, A. and Ullman, J. (1977) Find in CUMINCAD Principles of compiler design , Reading Mass: Addison-Wesley Publishing Co.
100%; open Banham, R. (1960) Find in CUMINCAD Theory and design in the first machine age , New York: Praeger
100%; open Banham, R. (1969) Find in CUMINCAD The architecture of the well-tempered environment , London: Architectural Press
100%; open Chase, S.C. (1999) Find in CUMINCAD Grammar based design: Issues for User Interaction models , Media and design process. Proceedings of the 1999 Annual Conference of ACADIA, eds. O. Ataman and J. Bermudez, 198-210. Salt Lake City
100%; open Davis, M. (1994) Find in CUMINCAD Solvability, provability, definability: The collected works of Emil L. Post (contemporary mathematicians) , Boston, Basel, Berlin: Birkhauser
100%; open Fleisher, A. (1992) Find in CUMINCAD Grammatical architecture , Environment and Planning B, 8:221-226
100%; open Foley, J.D. and Van Dam, A. (1982) Find in CUMINCAD Fundamentals of interactive computer graphics , Reading, Mass: Addison-Wesely
100%; open Frampton, K. (1995) Find in CUMINCAD Studies in tectonic culture: The poetics of construction in the nineteenth and twentieth century architecture , Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press
100%; open Gerzso, J.M. (1978) Find in CUMINCAD A descriptive theory of architectural built form and its applications , Ph.D. Dissertation, University Microfilms
100%; open Gerzso, J.M. (2000) Find in CUMINCAD Generating trullo Italian vernacular architecture with production rules and executable drawings , Proceedings of the millennial open symposium on the arts and interdisciplinary computing, eds. D. Salesin and C. Sequin. Seattle, WA: University of Washington
100%; open Gerzso, J.M. (2001) Find in CUMINCAD Automatic generation of layouts of an utzon housing system via the internet , Reinventing the discourse. Proceedings of the 2001 annual conference of ACADIA, ed. W. Jabi. State University of New York at Buffalo. Buffalo: New York
100%; open Gips, J. (1974) Find in CUMINCAD Shape grammars and their uses , Memo AIM 231, Palo Alto, CA: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratory, Computer Science Dept., Stanford University
100%; open Habraken, J. (1976) Find in CUMINCAD Variations: The systematic design of supports , Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
100%; open Hersey, G. and Freedman, R. (1992) Find in CUMINCAD Possible Palladian villas (plus a few instructively impossible ones) , Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press
100%; open Hutchings, E. (1997) Find in CUMINCAD Surely you’re joking, Mr. Feynman! , Adventures of a curious character. New York, London: W.W. Norton
100%; open Liew, H. (2002) Find in CUMINCAD Descriptive conventions for shape grammars , ACADIA 2002: thresholds. Proceedings of the 2002 annual conference of ACADIA, ed. G. Proctor, 369-382. Pamona, CA., Dept. Architecture, College of Environmental Design, California State Polytechnic University.
100%; open Minsky, M. (1967) Find in CUMINCAD Computation: Infinite and finite machines , Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice Hall
100%; open Mitchell, W. (1990) Find in CUMINCAD Logic of architecture , Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press
100%; open Rozenberg, G. (et al.) (1997) Find in CUMINCAD Handbook of graph grammars and computing by graph transformations: Concurrency, parallelism, and distribution , World Scientific Pub. Co.

last changed 2003/10/30 15:20
HOMELOGIN (you are user _anon_271716 from group guest) Works Powered by SciX Open Publishing Services 1.002